Yes, with a written agreement that covers who pays what, who lives there, and a firm sale date. Both of you stay on the mortgage and title until it sells, so lenders, renewals and repairs remain joint decisions. Most family lawyers treat this as a short transition rather than a long-term plan.
Keeping the house together, with neither spouse buying out the other, makes sense in one narrow case: a short, defined period with a firm sale date in writing, usually to get the children to the end of a school year. Beyond that, it is the same arrangement as waiting for the market, with a nicer name.
The agreement has to answer the questions the two of you will otherwise argue about later. Who pays the mortgage, the property tax and the insurance each month. Who lives in the house, and whether anyone else can. Who pays for the roof or the furnace if one goes. What happens when the mortgage comes up for renewal and the lender wants both signatures. And the date the house goes on the market, whatever the market is doing that month.
The arrangement that reliably goes wrong is the unwritten one, where somebody pays and assumes it gets sorted out at closing. There is no default answer in law for who carries the house while you both still own it. Have your family lawyer draft the agreement before you rely on it.
Most couples who hold the house are doing it because selling now means taking a loss. The cost of waiting is usually larger than it looks. The carrying cost keeps running every month, now paid from two households instead of one. The two of you stay on one mortgage, one title and one set of decisions. Neither of you can plan the next home while the capital is locked in this one, and a house held in common keeps the separation agreement from being final, which is the document most lenders want before they qualify either of you alone.
If one of you can carry the house alone and wants to stay, a buyout ends the wait cleanly. If neither of you can, selling during the separation splits any loss between you instead of one person wearing all of it later.
The Flowers Team has handled 50 divorce-related transactions since January 2024, and in 2026, 1 in every 7 Flowers Team transactions involves a separating household (Source: Flowers Team internal records, January 2024 to September 2026). When a couple decides to hold for a defined period, we help set the sale date now, so the wait has an end.
This is general information, not legal advice. Your family lawyer confirms how these rules apply to your situation.
Read what waiting for the market actually costs, and when taking the loss is the right call
Read whether to sell the house or buy out your spouse
Read how a spouse buyout works in Ontario
Ask for a free home evaluation