Top Rated Pizza Places in Milton

Flowers Team Real Estate • February 3, 2025

Top Rated Pizza Places in Milton: A Slice of Heaven Right Here in Town

Two pizzas are sitting on top of each other on a table.

Milton may be known for its charming neighbourhoods and thriving real estate market, but let’s talk about something just as important—pizza! Whether you're a fan of thin crust, deep dish, or classic Neapolitan-style, this town has some serious contenders for the best pizza. If you're on the hunt for your next slice of cheesy goodness, here are the top 10 pizza places in Milton that you need to try.

No matter the occasion—whether it’s game night, a weekend party, or just a late-night craving, these pizza spots have got you covered!


1. Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza

📍 Address: 22 Ontario St S, Milton, ON

If you want authentic wood-fired pizza, Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza is a must-visit. Their Neapolitan-style pies are cooked to perfection, with a light and airy crust. Try their Margherita Pizza for a classic Italian experience. Visit their website


2. Pizzaiolo

📍 Address: 327 Bronte St S Unit 2, Milton, ON

For a variety of gourmet and classic pizzas, Pizzaiolo is a go-to spot. They offer an extensive menu, including vegan and gluten-free options. Their Meat Lover’s Pizza is a local favourite. Visit their website


3. Big Mama's & Papa's Pizzeria

📍 Address: 785 Main St E #9, Milton, ON

If you’re craving oversized pizzas, Big Mama’s & Papa’s Pizzeria is the place to be. Their unique toppings and giant-sized pizzas make them stand out. Visit their website


4. Pasqualino

📍 Address: 248 Main St E, Milton, ON

For a high-end pizza experience, Pasqualino delivers authentic Italian-style pizza with high-quality ingredients. Their Prosciutto Arugula Pizza is a must-try. Visit their website


5. Luigi's Lasagna & Pizzeria

📍 Address: 159 Main St E, Milton, ON

A staple in Milton, Luigi’s Lasagna & Pizzeria offers hearty and delicious pizzas at affordable prices. Their Deluxe Special is a crowd favourite. Visit their website


6. City South Pizza Milton

📍 Address: 100 Bronte St S, Milton, ON

If you're looking for quick and budget-friendly takeout, City South Pizza has got you covered. Their BBQ Chicken Pizza is a standout option. Visit their website


7. Super Deal Pizza & Wings

📍 Address: 327 Bronte St S, Milton, ON

For a truly budget-friendly pizza, Super Deal Pizza & Wings delivers quality at a low price. Their Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza is perfect for a simple yet satisfying meal. Visit their website


8. Topper's Pizza

📍 Address: 10220 Derry Rd #105, Milton, ON

A Canadian favourite, Topper’s Pizza is known for its Topper’s Creamy Garlic Base and endless topping options. Their Butter Chicken Pizza is a must-try. Visit their website


9. Jopapas Pizza & Wings

📍 Address: 91 Main St E, Milton, ON

A great place for pizza and wings, Jopapas Pizza & Wings serves up delicious pizzas with generous toppings. Their Supreme Pizza is a hit among locals. Visit their website


10. Portabello's Italian Bistro

📍 Address: 101 James Snow Pkwy N, Milton, ON

For a blend of Italian cuisine and gourmet pizza, Portabello’s Italian Bistro is an excellent choice. Their Fig & Prosciutto Pizza is a delightful mix of sweet and savoury flavors. Visit their website


Special Mention: Marquee Steakhouse

📍 Address: 204 Main St E, Milton, ON

While primarily known for its premium steaks and elegant dining experience, Marquee Steakhouse also serves up some incredibly delicious wood-fired pizzas. If you're looking for a sophisticated yet comforting pizza option, this is the place to be. Visit their website


The Final Slice 🍕

Whether you're looking for authentic Italian, a quick and budget-friendly option, or something totally gourmet, Milton has a pizza spot for you. Next time you’re craving a slice—whether it’s for the big game, a weekend party, or a midnight snack—give one of these top-rated places a try!


JOIN OUR NEWSLETTER

Newsletter Signup

Flowers Team News

Two skaters on a frozen pond at sunset, with snowy trees and a colorful winter sky.
By Amy Flowers | Flowers Team Real Estate September 10, 2026
This country home for sale near Milton is where one family learned to skate on the pond, watched deer, and grew up on 10 acres. Book a private viewing to see it.
Person using a power drill to install a white shelf frame near a doorway.
By Amy Flowers | Flowers Team Real Estate September 10, 2026
Get your Milton home ready for fall with our September home maintenance checklist. From furnaces and gutters to roofs, windows, lawns and outdoor faucets.
deer standing near a spring-fed pond on a country property near Milton, Ontario
By Amy Flowers | Flowers Team Real Estate September 4, 2026
Country living near Milton is closer than you think, with acreage, ponds, and privacy just 25 minutes from town and the 401. See what rural life really offers.
Ferris wheel cabins silhouetted against a bright sunset sky with trees in the foreground
By Amy Flowers | Flowers Team Real Estate September 3, 2026
Planning to visit the Milton Fall Fair in 2026? Dates, location, activities, the Urban Agriculture theme and helpful tips for September 25–27 in Milton, Ontario.
Aerial view of a large house surrounded by trees, lawns, and a driveway in a wooded rural area
By Amy Flowers | Flowers Team Real Estate September 2, 2026
A 6,200 sq ft detached home on 2.7 acres in rural Milton, Ontario. Step inside 4215 Ennisclare Drive, the family who built it, and a full year on the land.
Luxury living room with text “Staging vs Interior Decorating” and “What is the difference?”
By By the Flowers Team · Featuring Amy Flowers, Broker and CEO. September 1, 2026
Home staging and interior decorating are not the same. Learn the key differences and why Milton sellers who skip staging leave money on the table. Flowers Team.
Autumn forest path covered in fallen leaves, with golden trees arching overhead
By Amy Flowers | Flowers Team Real Estate August 27, 2026
Discover the best places to see fall colours in Milton, Ontario in 2026. Explore Rattlesnake Point, Hilton Falls, Crawford Lake, Kelso, Mill Pond and fall scenery.
Aerial view of a forested neighborhood with homes and lawns amid dense green trees under a cloudy sky
By Amy Flowers | Flowers Team Real Estate August 24, 2026
Ennisclare Woods is a 29-home estate community in rural Milton with 90 acres of shared woodland. Learn how the common land, fees and trails work. Book a review.