Should You Buy a Home or Keep Renting? Key Considerations to Help You Decide

Amy Flowers Team • May 11, 2021

Are you planning to rent or buy a home anytime soon? It’s no secret COVID-19 has created a lot of uncertainty, but you’ll be excited to know that the Canadian housing market is booming.


As a potential first-time buyer, you’ll want to know whether you should continue renting or become a homeowner. This decision is a difficult one driven by both financial and lifestyle factors. It also depends on individual preferences too, so no single answer can apply to everyone.


What are the advantages and disadvantages of renting a home versus buying a house in Ontario? 

Take some time to think about the key considerations when deciding between buying a home or renting a property.


The Cost

It’s no secret that homeownership can be a significant investment. On top of the down payment, there are also the regular carrying costs, which include things like your mortgage, insurance, utilities, maintenance, and property taxes. And with condos, make sure to budget for your monthly condo fees.


When it comes to rentals, you need to expect that your rent will increase every year based on the latest rent increase guidelines. You may also be responsible for sudden moving costs should your landlord decide to take possession of the house or look to sell.


Buying a house in Ontario is an incredibly attractive option for many, given that low interest rates have made it easier for first-time buyers to find that perfect home.


The Location

Prices vary when it comes to renting or buying in different regions. Prices in Toronto and the GTA tend to be higher due to larger populations and increasing demand.


However, the shift to remote work has caused housing booms in many non-traditional markets as younger buyers look to settle down in quieter communities outside of Toronto and the GTA.


Location plays an important role in what schools, parks, and amenities are available—so it’s important to understand what a particular location has to offer. You will also want to take into account local property taxes since they are city-specific.


The Time Frame

You must also factor in how long you expect to stay at your new property. A rule of thumb is to rent if you’re thinking of moving out after three years and buy if you plan to stay for at least five.


Why is this? The cost of quickly buying and selling a house is high. You have the transaction fees, moving costs, legal fees, and early termination fees for terminating a mortgage.


If you are looking for a short-term place to live, renting may be the better option. The added flexibility provided by renting gives you a lot of control that you may not be able to enjoy if you have a fixed-rate mortgage.


However, the longer you expect to stay at your future property, the more attractive the option of buying a house is since real estate is a long-term investment that appreciates over time. 


So, how do you decide how long you will stay in a single location? Answer this question by taking into account your lifestyle needs and future work opportunities.

  • Will you be welcoming new members into the family, or will a few move out soon?
  • Will your work require you to travel in the future?
  • Are the amenities and services around the location enough for you to stay?


If you’re choosing to purchase a home, you want to minimize the chance you will need to move again soon.


Looking to Buy a Home in Milton? Work With Milton’s #1 Real Estate Team

Should I buy or rent in Milton? That’s a popular question we get asked a lot.


Are you looking for rentals in Milton? Buying may be the better long-term option for you. If you’re looking to explore all of your opportunities, get in touch with Milton’s #1 real estate team.


Amy Flowers can help you find the perfect house for sale in Milton.
Get in touch today with our team today to learn more.

Flowers Team News

By Flowers Team Real Estate October 27, 2025
Celebrate the Season! 2025 Santa Claus Parades in Toronto, Peel Region, and Halton Area
By Flowers Team Real Estate October 27, 2025
Discover the Magic of Holiday Markets Around Milton, Oakville, Burlington, Mississauga, and Georgetown in 2025
Spacious bedroom with a bed, seating area by a large window, and neutral tones.
By Flowers Team Real Estate October 14, 2025
Get your home market-ready before the snow falls. From boosting curb appeal and winterizing systems to cozy staging and safety tips, here’s how to sell your home faster and for more value this winter.
By Flowers Team Real Estate October 4, 2025
Interest Rate Cuts Spark Buyer Optimism September brought a renewed sense of confidence to Milton homebuyers as the Bank of Canada’s recent interest rate cut created more favourable borrowing conditions. This shift made monthly mortgage payments slightly more manageable, encouraging renewed activity—though Milton’s market is still clearly favouring buyers. “The Bank of Canada’s September interest rate cut was welcome news for homebuyers,” said TRREB President Elechia Barry-Sproule. “With lower borrowing costs, more households are now able to afford monthly mortgage payments on a home that meets their needs.” Sales Hold Steady, Inventory Climbs In September 2025, Milton recorded 132 home sales, holding steady with August. However, new inventory surged 16 percent month-over-month, reaching 431 listings. This increase in supply, paired with consistent sales, resulted in a Sales-to-New-Listings Ratio of 0.31 — down from 0.36 in August. This ratio firmly positions Milton in buyer’s market territory. Compared to September 2024, sales were up nearly 4 percent, while new listings jumped by 14.6 percent, giving homebuyers more options to explore. Prices Rebound Month-over-Month Milton's average sale price climbed to $1,036,162 in September — up a strong 7.5 percent from August 2025, and modestly up 1.4 percent year-over-year. Median prices tell a similar story, rising to $955,000, a 4.7 percent monthly increase. These gains suggest that while buyers are cautious, well-priced and desirable homes are still commanding strong offers. However, it’s important to note that price growth was segment-dependent, with detached homes and townhouses seeing more buyer traction than others.
By Flowers Team Real Estate September 4, 2025
Milton Real Estate Market Update: August 2025 Inventory Up, Sales Slip – A Buyer’s Market in Milton As summer winds down, Milton’s housing market reflected broader regional trends, with a modest shift in buyer behaviour and a noticeable rise in inventory. According to the latest data compiled by the Flowers Team, 132 homes were sold in August 2025 , marking a small 0.76% increase compared to August 2024. But what stands out most is the sharp growth in new listings , which jumped 22.85% year-over-year , bringing the total new inventory to 371 homes. This uptick in listings has tipped the scales in favour of buyers. With a sales-to-new listings ratio of 36% , Milton firmly sits in a buyer’s market , where supply is outpacing demand and buyers have more leverage in price negotiations. Average Prices See Sharp Drop Year-Over-Year The average sale price in Milton for August 2025 dropped to $964,086 , down 9.43% from the same month last year. The median price also reflected this trend, landing at $912,500 , which represents a decrease of 8.76% year-over-year . Compared to just last month (July 2025), the average price has dropped another 5.79% , reinforcing the current cooling conditions in the market. Milton’s detached home segment saw the largest drop in activity, with only 55 sales in August , down a staggering 36% from the previous month. Semi-detached homes fared worse, down 68% month-over-month . Only 7 semi-detached homes were sold this August compared to 22 in July . Townhouses and condos remained flat in activity but also faced downward pricing pressure. Expert Voices Weigh In on Market Conditions “Compared to last year, we have seen a modest increase in home sales over the summer,” noted TRREB President Elechia Barry-Sproule . “With the economy slowing and inflation under control, additional interest rate cuts by the Bank of Canada could help offset the impact of tariffs. Greater affordability would not only support more home sales but also generate significant economic spin-off benefits.” Echoing this sentiment, TRREB Chief Information Officer Jason Mercer emphasized the affordability barrier still facing many buyers. “A household earning the average income in the GTA is still finding it challenging to afford the monthly mortgage payment associated with the purchase of an average priced home,” he said. “Further relief in borrowing costs would see an increased number of buyers move off the sidelines to take advantage of today’s well-supplied market.”
Kitchen renovation in progress, cabinets and a worker with a saw.
By Flowers Team Real Estate August 21, 2025
Should you renovate before selling your Milton home? Learn which upgrades buyers want, typical ROI, and how to decide if renovations are worth it before listing.
By Flowers Team Real Estate August 8, 2025
Milton Real Estate Market Update – July 2025 Home Sales Rebound as Buyers Regain Confidence The real estate market in Milton, Ontario saw a noticeable upswing this July, echoing broader trends across the Greater Toronto Area (GTA). With affordability improving and consumer confidence rising, more buyers are stepping back into the market. Let’s explore the highlights from Milton’s July 2025 real estate performance. Home Sales Surge Over 40% Compared to Last Year Milton experienced 181 home sales in July 2025— a 40.3% increase from the 129 sales in July 2024. This marks the strongest July sales performance in years , and suggests that affordability and buyer motivation are moving in a positive direction. The increase in sales outpaced the growth in new listings, tightening market conditions and increasing the sales-to-new-listings ratio to 38% , up from 33% last year. “Improved affordability, brought about by lower home prices and borrowing costs, is starting to translate into increased home sales,” said TRREB President Elechia Barry-Sproule . “More relief is required, particularly where borrowing costs are concerned, but it’s clear that a growing number of households are finding affordable options for homeownership.” Average Prices Slide, But Momentum Builds The average sale price in Milton for July 2025 was $1,023,334 , down 6.1% from July 2024 , and 4% lower than June 2025 . Similarly, the median sale price dipped to $975,000 , down 5.1% year-over-year . While prices have softened, this appears to be encouraging buyers to make their move, as demand gains traction month-over-month. “Recent data suggest that the Canadian economy is treading water in the face of trade uncertainty with the United States,” said TRREB Chief Information Officer Jason Mercer . “The housing sector can be a catalyst for growth… Further interest rate cuts would spur home sales and see more spin-off expenditures, positively impacting the economy and job growth.”
A model house is sitting next to stacks of coins on a table.
By Flowers Team Real Estate July 31, 2025
Selling your Milton home? Know the real costs from commissions to staging and moving. Plan ahead to avoid surprises and boost your profit.
A man in a suit is talking to two women in front of a brick building.
By Flowers Team Real Estate July 31, 2025
Avoid six costly mistakes when buying a home in Milton. Get pre-approved, budget for closing costs, schedule inspections, and plan ahead to secure your ideal property.
A crowd of people holding rainbow flags in their hands
By Flowers Team Real Estate July 16, 2025
Downtown Milton is set to brighten with Halton’s Third Annual Pride Parade, followed by the first-ever Pride in the Park festival.