57 Victoria St | Milton, Ontario

Detached For Sale

$3,995,000

57 Victoria St | Milton, Ontario

Neighbourhood: Old Milton


Known as The Judge’s House, 57 Victoria Street is one of Milton’s most iconic addresses — set on over half an acre backing onto protected conservation land, and fully rebuilt in a two-year transformation that merges Victorian heritage architecture with modern luxury. Every inch of this 4,100+ sq ft home was redesigned with intention — from the handcrafted oak staircase to the preserved oak front foyer, radiant Warmboard subflooring, and Northern Wide Plank hardwood throughout. The layout at the front of the home honours a more traditional flow, with dedicated rooms including a formal sitting room and home office, while the rear opens into a contemporary plan with expansive sightlines and integrated living spaces. The main floor is anchored by two striking Valor fireplaces — one classic in tone, the other sleek and modern — alongside custom millwork and conservation-approved Kolbe windows that flood the home with natural light. The kitchen is a standout, featuring Villa cabinetry, Han Stone surfaces, a hidden coffee station, and a sculptural Elica hood fan that disappears into the ceiling line. The primary suite offers double walk-in closets with display lighting, and a spa-calibre ensuite with heated floors, oversized glass shower, and a sculptural tub. Construction quality is unmatched: steel support beams, DryShield waterproofing, sound-insulated walls, and an energy audit confirming exceptional R-values. The home includes discreet air systems and an independently zoned lower level for complete comfort. A fully detached, 1,050 sq ft coach house includes epoxy garage floors, a custom dog wash station, and a radiant-heated studio with six skylights, floor-to-ceiling windows, and a full 3-piece bathroom. The lot is enclosed with Iron Eagle fencing, features a 31-zone irrigation system, and is pre-wired for a future electric gate. A once-in-a-generation blend of legacy, location, and lasting quality.

 

CALL AGENT

Amy Flowers

Overview of  57 Victoria St | Milton, Ontario 

A black and white drawing of a credit card on a white background.

W12245625

A black and white drawing of arrows pointing in opposite directions on a white background.

5227 Sq Ft

A black and white drawing of a bed with a person laying in it.

4+1

A black and white drawing of a bathtub with a shower head.

4+1

KITCHEN

GOURMET KITCHEN


• Mix of framed and frameless cabinetry by Villa Kitchens with a hidden coffee station.


• Hand picked high-end appliances including Sub-Zero, Wolf, Miele.

 

• Elica Italian recessed ceiling hood fan – minimalist and powerful. 


• Built-in Culligan water purification and softener system. 


• Custom Han Stone counter tops & window sills and recessed cabinetry lighting.


• Expertly crafted built in coffee station


• Recessed undermount and interior cabinetry lighting



LIVING & DINING

LIVING ROOM


• The living room offers a quiet sense of grandeur. Northern Wide Plank hardwood runs throughout, grounding the space with warmth and continuity.


• Every window has been purposefully positioned to frame curated views of the landscaping beyond — no matter where you sit, the outside has been considered as part of the inside experience. 


• Each room offers a different garden view — from structured boxwoods to lilacs to magnolia blooms — thoughtfully planted to connect with the interior aesthetic.


• The fireplace here leans traditional, with a custom mantle that once again blends Victorian architecture with modern restraint. And yes — the marble surround is echoed from the showstopping fireplace in the office, pulling that rich stone palette through the main floor.



BEDS & BATHS

BEDROOMS & BATHROOMS


• Walk-in California Closets in every bedroom, with lit display cabinetry in the primary.


• Each bathroom has heated tile flooring


• Primary suite includes: heated floors, double closets, and electronic blinds by Maxxmar,  large-format porcelain tile, freestanding 


• Claybrook SoHo marble tub, oversized luxurious shower in the primary bathroom. 


• Jack & Jill bathroom with extra-long tub and coordinated fixtures, double vanity sinks & swinging glass surround.


• Ensuite in west-facing bedroom features seamless shower and warmboard floors with push-access panel.


 

BASEMENT

• DryShield interior & exterior waterproofing with sump pump system. 


• Fully finished with epoxy floors and moisture-resistant wall board (no drywall).


• Basement functions as its own independent environment with independant air circulation.


PROPERTY VIDEO

VIRTUAL TOUR

GOOGLE MAPS

FEATURES

 

THE HOME 


• Fully rebuilt from the exterior bricks (2022–2024), including steel support beams & Dry Shield waterproofing


• Historic charm meets modern luxury in this Victorian-inspired showpiece, rebuilt to exacting standards


• Over half an acre in the heart of downtown Milton, backing onto protected conservation land


• Known locally as Felsgarth Manor (aka “The Judge’s House” or “The Doctor’s House”)


INTERIOR HIGHLIGHTS


• Northern Wide Plank hardwood throughout (main home + coach house) with Warmboard radiant heating for fast, efficient comfort. 


• Floor to ceiling double hung Kolbe windows in the primary living spaces


• Original oak wood preserved in the foyer for character and historical integrity.


• Custom arched doorways and statement oak staircase centerpiece tie in the Victorian theme with contemporary elegance.


 


 

Interested in 57 Victoria St | Milton, Ontario?

Get in touch now!

Property Listing Contact Form