Detached For Sale

$3,649,900

57 Victoria St | Milton, Ontario

Neighbourhood: Old Milton

Book A Consultation

Call Us

Property Description

Set on a rare half-acre backing onto protected conservation land, 57 Victoria Street offers a level of privacy and calm rarely found within town limits.

Surrounded by mature trees and curated gardens, the home feels intentionally removed, with each window framing a quiet connection to the outdoors. It's a setting that offers true serenity without isolation.

Known as The Judges House, this is one of Milton's most iconic addresses, reimagined through a complete two-year, $2 million transformation that merges its Victorian architecture with an uncompromising standard of modern living.

With over 5,000 sq ft, the home is designed for both presence and ease. A more traditional front layout transitions into an open rear living space, creating a natural balance between structure and flow.

Light moves effortlessly throughout, enhanced by expansive windows, refined millwork, and thoughtfully integrated living spaces. Every finish, fixture, and system has been specified without compromise - a home that performs as beautifully as it looks.

A fully detached two-storey coach house is a self-contained residence that introduces rare flexibility, ideal for a private workspace, studio, or guest residence, set apart from the main home.

While the setting feels calm and removed, seamless access to the city and a short walk to Main Street create a true sense of escape without compromise or isolation.

A rare offering defined by privacy, scale, and architectural significance.

CALL AGENT

Amy Flowers

Overview of 57 Victoria St | Milton, Ontario

FEATURES

THE HOME

• Fully rebuilt from the exterior bricks (2022–2024), including steel support beams & Dry Shield waterproofing

• Historic charm meets modern luxury in this Victorian-inspired showpiece, rebuilt to exacting standards

• Over half an acre in the heart of downtown Milton, backing onto protected conservation land

• Known locally as Felsgarth Manor (aka “The Judge’s House” or “The Doctor’s House”)

INTERIOR HIGHLIGHTS

• Northern Wide Plank hardwood throughout (main home + coach house) with Warmboard radiant heating for fast, efficient comfort.

• Floor to ceiling double hung Kolbe windows in the primary living spaces

• Original oak wood preserved in the foyer for character and historical integrity.

• Custom arched doorways and statement oak staircase centerpiece tie in the Victorian theme with contemporary elegance.

Property Stats

MLS

W13144694

Sq Ft

5227 Sq Ft

Bed

4+1

Bath

4+1

KITCHEN

GOURMET KITCHEN

• Mix of framed and frameless cabinetry by Villa Kitchens with a hidden coffee station.

• Hand picked high-end appliances including Sub-Zero, Wolf, Miele.

• Elica Italian recessed ceiling hood fan – minimalist and powerful.

• Built-in Culligan water purification and softener system.

• Custom Han Stone counter tops & window sills and recessed cabinetry lighting.

• Expertly crafted built in coffee station

• Recessed undermount and interior cabinetry lighting

LIVING & DINING

LIVING ROOM

• The living room offers a quiet sense of grandeur. Northern Wide Plank hardwood runs throughout, grounding the space with warmth and continuity.

• Every window has been purposefully positioned to frame curated views of the landscaping beyond — no matter where you sit, the outside has been considered as part of the inside experience.

• Each room offers a different garden view — from structured boxwoods to lilacs to magnolia blooms — thoughtfully planted to connect with the interior aesthetic.

• The fireplace here leans traditional, with a custom mantle that once again blends Victorian architecture with modern restraint. And yes — the marble surround is echoed from the showstopping fireplace in the office, pulling that rich stone palette through the main floor.

BEDS & BATHS

BEDROOMS & BATHROOMS

• Walk-in California Closets in every bedroom, with lit display cabinetry in the primary.

• Each bathroom has heated tile flooring

• Primary suite includes: heated floors, double closets, and electronic blinds by Maxxmar, large-format porcelain tile, freestanding

• Claybrook SoHo marble tub, oversized luxurious shower in the primary bathroom.

• Jack & Jill bathroom with extra-long tub and coordinated fixtures, double vanity sinks & swinging glass surround.

• Ensuite in west-facing bedroom features seamless shower and warmboard floors with push-access panel.

BASEMENT

• DryShield interior & exterior waterproofing with sump pump system.

• Fully finished with epoxy floors and moisture-resistant wall board (no drywall).

• Basement functions as its own independent environment with independant air circulation.

PROPERTY VIDEO

VIRTUAL TOUR

GOOGLE MAPS

Interested in 57 Victoria St | Milton, Ontario?

Get in touch now!

Property Listing Contact Form

Buyer Faq's

How do I know how much house I can actually afford in Ontario?

Start with your income, debts, down payment, and monthly costs. A lender pre-approval plus a realistic budget will show what feels affordable, not just what you qualify for.

What is the minimum down payment required to buy a home in Ontario right now?

Usually at least 5% of the first $500,000 and 10% of the portion from $500,000 to $1.5M. If you put down less than 20%, mortgage default insurance usually applies.

Should I get pre-approved for a mortgage before I start looking?

Yes, getting pre-approved early helps you understand your price range, monthly payment, and borrowing limits before you start viewing homes or making offers.

What kind of mortgage should I get — fixed, variable, or something else?

It depends on your budget, risk tolerance, and how long you plan to keep the mortgage. Fixed offers payment stability, while variable can offer flexibility and lower penalties in some cases.

How much are closing costs when buying a home in Ontario?

Many Ontario buyers should budget roughly 1.5% to 4% of the purchase price for closing costs, depending on land transfer tax, legal fees, inspections, title insurance, and adjustments.

What is Ontario land transfer tax and do first-time buyers get a rebate?

Ontario land transfer tax is a provincial closing cost based on the purchase price. Eligible first-time buyers may qualify for a rebate of up to $4,000.

What makes a neighbourhood a good location in Ontario?

A great location usually balances commute, schools, amenities, safety, resale potential, and the lifestyle you want day to day.

How long does the home-buying process take in Ontario?

Many Ontario purchases take about 30 to 90 days from accepted offer to closing, but the full buying journey can be longer depending on financing, search time, and conditions.

Do I really need a home inspection?

Not always, but a home inspection can reveal costly issues before you commit. It is especially valuable for older homes, unique properties, or homes with visible wear.

How do I calculate monthly homeownership costs in Ontario?

Add your mortgage payment, property taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance, and any condo fees. That full monthly number is what homeownership really costs.

How are property taxes calculated in Ontario?

In Ontario, property tax is based on your home’s MPAC-assessed value multiplied by your municipality’s annual tax rate, plus any local charges or adjustments.

Can I buy a home in Ontario with little or no down payment?

No-down-payment purchases are rare. Most buyers need at least 5% down, and anything under 20% usually requires mortgage default insurance and strong qualification.

How does the mortgage stress test work and how does it affect me?

You usually have to qualify at the higher of your contract rate plus 2% or 5.25%, which can reduce the amount you are approved to borrow.

What first-time home buyer programs exist in Ontario?

Common programs include the FHSA, Home Buyers’ Plan, Home Buyers’ Amount tax credit, and Ontario land transfer tax rebates for eligible first-time buyers.

Should I buy a condo or a detached house in Ontario?

A condo can be more affordable and lower-maintenance, while a detached home offers more space, privacy, and control. The right choice depends on lifestyle and budget.

What questions should I ask when viewing a property?

Ask about the home’s age, updates, known issues, monthly costs, inclusions, neighbourhood, utility bills, and any rules that could affect how you use the property.

How do I choose the right real estate agent as a buyer in Ontario?

Choose an agent with strong local knowledge, clear communication, honest advice, and a track record helping buyers in your price range and target areas.

What happens if I change my mind after I make an offer?

If your offer is firm, backing out can put your deposit at risk and expose you to damages. If conditions are still open, you may still have a way out before the deadline.

Is it better to rent or buy a home in Ontario right now?

It depends on how long you plan to stay, your real monthly costs, and how much flexibility you need. Buying builds equity, but renting can make more sense in the short term.

What is different about buying a pre-construction home in Ontario?

Pre-construction usually means longer timelines, staged deposits, possible delays, assignment rules, and occupancy fees before final closing. It can offer customization, but it adds uncertainty.

Do new homes in Ontario come with a warranty?

Most new homes in Ontario come with Tarion-backed warranty coverage, but what is covered depends on the issue and timeline. Always review the warranty information sheet.

How do I buy an investment or rental property in Ontario?

Start with financing, projected rent, carrying costs, vacancy risk, and landlord rules. A good rental purchase works on cash flow, tenant demand, and long-term resale potential.

What credit score do I need to get the best mortgage rate in Canada?

There is no single magic score, but borrowers with strong credit, stable income, and low debt usually get the best pricing. In practice, 680+ often opens more options.

What are the biggest mistakes first-time buyers make in Ontario?

Common mistakes include shopping before pre-approval, skipping closing-cost planning, stretching the budget, ignoring monthly carrying costs, and moving too fast on the wrong home.